Materials Science CELIA MALFATTI | Materials Science | Women Researcher Award 2026

Posted on 20/02/202620/02/2026 by Innovator Awards

CELIA MALFATTI | Materials Science | Women Researcher Award

### Review Form

Reviewer Evaluation Form

Please evaluate the nominee based on the criteria below. Score each item from 1 (lowest) to 5 (highest), then provide your overall comments and recommendation. After submission, you will see a link to request your Reviewer Membership Certificate.

Optional: Fetch your reviewer details from ORCID.

ORCID iD (e.g. 0000-0002-1825-0097 or full URL):

Reviewer Name(Required)

Reviewer Affiliation(Required)

Reviewer Country

Reviewer Email(Required)

Please provide your email. Your Reviewer Membership Certificate link will be sent to this address

1. Research Contribution & Quality(Required)

Please enter a number from 1 to 5.

Significance, strength, and overall quality of the candidate’s research work.

2. Innovation & Originality(Required)

Please enter a number from 1 to 5.

Novelty, creativity, and originality of the research outputs.

3. Research Presence & Profiles(Required)

Please enter a number from 1 to 5.

Strength of Scopus, Google Scholar, ORCID, and overall research visibility.

4. Research Impact(Required)

Please enter a number from 1 to 5.

Citations, h-index, journal quality, and influence within the field.

5. Overall Award Suitability(Required)

Please enter a number from 1 to 5.

Fit of the candidate with the award category and relevance to the subject area.

Total Score

Recommendation(Required)

Reviewer Comments(Required)

Brief justification of the scores and recommendation, including observations on ethical conduct, research integrity, publication quality, and any potential conflicts of interest.

Display my details(Required)

Show my name and affiliation

Show only my name

Hide my name and affiliation (anonymous)

Remaining review slots for this entry: 3 of 3

### Review Comments & Scores

Reviews are visible only to the nominee and authorized staff.